- Details
-
Category: Educational
-
Created: Monday, 28 January 2008 22:45
-
Published: Monday, 28 January 2008 22:31
-
Written by David, Co-relating
-
Hits: 3985
{amazon id='0743203046'}
It’s been slow around these parts lately, but I went to a talk last Thursday that I wanted to write a bit about. Robert Putnam, most known as the author of Bowling Alone, was here at Stanford talking about his controversial new work. In Bowling Alone Putnam argued that America’s social capital, its resources derived from social networks, has been declining over the past few decades. This means that people both belong to fewer organizations and have fewer friends than in the past. The title of the book refers to one example of this, that people still bowl quite a bit, but don’t do it in leagues like they used to. (And, as I previously blogged about one of last year’s most important sociology papers described a major decrease in the number of friends the average American has).
Putnam’s new work is about how these trends interrelate with America’s growing diversity. What Putnam found was troubling not only to many other political scientists and sociologists but to Putnam himself. Putnam and his associates surveyed 41 different and varied American communities and found that the ethnic and racial diversity of a community is strongly, and positively, correlated with how socially fragmented it is. In other words, the more diverse a location is, the less likely people of all backgrounds were to trust each other, to be friends with each other, and to belong to organizations with each other.
{josquote}Putnam pointed to two modern examples of institutions were participation does seem to increase cross-race friendships: the military and megachurches.{/josquote}
We have to be careful here because this finding has been largely distorted in the media to say that diversity causes poor race relations. That isn’t what the findings suggest, however as Putnam went through great pains to make clear. In this research diversity isn’t correlated with poor race relations, but rather poor social relations in general. If I’m white and live in a diverse area it's not that I trust my black, Asian and Latino neighbors less, it's that I trust everyone less. It's not that I have fewer black, Asian or Latino friends, I have fewer friends in general. What seems to happen is that people who live in diverse areas are just less likely to be engaged with their neighbors and with civic life (and more likely to be home watching TV). The story, in other words, is a strange and complicated one (and like any methodologist they control for as many possibly confounding factors as they can).
Full story...